How We Test

Last updated: October 2026

Every Agency Tested Score is an editorial research-desk assessment. We do not run hands-on tests, trial accounts, or test workspaces. Our assessments are built from three public sources: the vendor’s own documentation, current pricing pages, and verified user reports (G2, Capterra).

Assessment type: Research-desk assessment (vendor docs, pricing pages, verified user reports) — not a hands-on test cycle.

What we assess

Every tool is scored on the same five weighted criteria: Agency features (25%), Ease of use (20%), Pricing value (20%), Support (15%), Integrations (20%). The combined score is the weighted sum, shown as X/10.

Our 5-step process

  1. Read the vendor docs — features, limits, and plan differences, exactly as an agency would encounter them.
  2. Price it like an agency — current pricing pages, per-seat math for 5, 15, and 40-person teams, plus hidden costs.
  3. Listen to verified users — G2 and Capterra review aggregates: what agencies praise and what they complain about.
  4. Score independently — the five weighted criteria, no vendor input. Commissions never move rankings.
  5. Publish everything — full score breakdown, sources, and date stamps on every assessment.

What the scores mean

ScoreMeaning
9.0 – 10Exceptional — the benchmark for the category
8.0 – 8.9Excellent — our recommendation for most agencies
7.0 – 7.9Good — strong in places, with real tradeoffs to weigh
6.0 – 6.9Okay — usable, but only for narrow use cases
Below 6.0Not recommended for agencies

Editorial estimates

Alongside our expert score, every review shows a user-satisfaction percentage marked with an asterisk. This is an editorial estimate compiled from public review aggregates (G2, Capterra, and similar sources) at the time of assessment — not a survey we conducted and not a precise measurement. We include it as a sanity check against our own findings: when our score and user sentiment diverge sharply, we say so and explain why.

Re-check policy

SaaS products change constantly, so reviews carry a “Last updated” date. We re-check pricing on every review at least quarterly, and we re-assess tools when vendors ship major redesigns or pricing overhauls. A review that no longer reflects the product gets updated or retired — we do not leave stale verdicts ranking.

Independence and disclosure

Independence and affiliate disclosure: Agency Tested is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Vendors cannot pay for placement, scores, rankings, or verdicts — and affiliate relationships never influence assessment outcomes. Assessments are conducted independently, from public documentation and verified user reports, without vendor involvement.