Assessment summary. Assessment type: Research-desk assessment (vendor docs, pricing pages, verified user reports) — not a hands-on test cycle. Slack is team chat: channels, threads, huddles, a 2,600+ app directory, and Slack Connect for external orgs. Teams leave it for four distinct reasons — per-seat cost at headcount, an ecosystem already paid for, the cheapest standalone seat with unlimited history, or self-hosted control — and each reason points to a different alternative. This article sorts by reason-for-leaving, not by a single “best alternative” ranking, and works every bill at real agency headcounts. 6 of 6 vendor pricing pages were read live in the browser on October 23, 2026 (Slack, Microsoft Teams, Google Workspace, Pumble, Discord, Mattermost); every ladder figure below is live-verified, and figures no vendor page publishes are hedged and labelled. Last updated: October 2026.
We may earn a commission if you buy through our links — it doesn’t change our verdicts.
Pricing checked: October 23, 2026 (live vendor pages).
Quick Answer: Leaving Slack over per-seat cost? Pumble Business puts unlimited-history chat with guest users at $3.99/seat/mo against Slack Pro’s $8.75. Already paying for Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace? Teams and Google Chat sit inside that bill — $0 incremental. Need the cheapest seat with unlimited history? Pumble Free is $0, forever. Running your own infrastructure? Mattermost self-hosted carries a $0 licence plus hosting. Discord is $0 with the best voice channels — but it is not a business tool. Match the exit to the reason.
Don’t pick the best Slack alternative. Pick the exit that matches why you’re leaving.
Buyer-segment cards
- Freelancers & boutiques (1–5 people): Price and simplicity dominate. Pumble Free for unlimited history at $0; Pumble Business ($3.99/seat) the moment client guests enter the picture; Google Chat at $0 incremental if the shop already pays for Workspace Starter.
- Growing full-service agencies (6–25 people): Client communication and admin controls dominate. Teams at $0 incremental inside Microsoft 365 Business Basic ($7) for Microsoft shops; Google Chat at $0 incremental inside Workspace Starter ($7) for Google shops; Pumble Business ($3.99) for shops buying chat standalone.
- Large & multi-brand agencies (25+ people): Compliance, permissions, and retention dominate. Teams on the Microsoft 365 Premium track ($22) for Microsoft-led orgs; Mattermost self-hosted or Enterprise for data-ownership requirements; Slack Business+ itself if SSO and compliance already justify $18/seat.
The Slack baseline: what you’re leaving (and the 90-day trap)
Slack’s pricing fact that starts every exit conversation: Pro at $8.75 per user per month compounds fast — a 50-person agency pays $5,250/yr on Pro list before any add-on, and $10,800/yr on Business+. (Full scored review: Slack review.)
Slack price ladder (read live on slack.com/pricing, October 23, 2026)
| Plan | Annual billing (per user/mo) | Monthly billing (per user/mo) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 | $0 (90-day visible history, up to 10 apps, 1:1 huddles, 1:1 Slack Connect, no AI) | Live vendor page |
| Pro | Not published on the vendor page | $8.75 (promo $4.38/mo for the first 3 months) | Live vendor page |
| Business+ | Not published on the vendor page | $18 (promo $9/mo for the first 3 months) | Live vendor page |
| Enterprise+ | Not published on the vendor page | Contact sales for pricing | Live vendor page |
Prices last verified: October 23, 2026 (live vendor pages).
Per-table source: read live in the browser on slack.com/pricing, October 23, 2026. The page shows monthly-billing prices only — there is no annual/monthly toggle — so the commonly quoted Pro $7.25 and Business+ $15 annual figures are NOT published on the vendor page. Enterprise+ supersedes our own #15 ($45 annual, Oct 14): the live page shows “Contact sales for pricing” with no $45 figure anywhere.
The 90-day trap, in the vendor’s own words. The pricing page states Free history is “saved and searchable for 90 days,” with an upgrade unlocking “the previous 12 months messages” — older messages are hidden until upgrade, not gone. Separately, the page’s comparison table states “Free Slack deletes data after one year. Paid subscriptions keep it for life by default, with adjustable settings.” Export history BEFORE cutover: do not start a migration on a Free workspace without pulling the archive first.
Promo, labelled as promo. The page shows struck-through monthly prices — $8.75 → $4.38 (Pro) and $18 → $9 (Business+) — 50% off for the first 3 months when buying Pro or Business+ online within the first 7 days of team creation. The promo T&C exclude annual plans and Enterprise+; limit one per customer. Promo, not list; standard pricing applies at renewal. Year one at 50 seats with the promo: 3 × $218.75 + 9 × $437.50 = $4,593.75 — shown for context; every bill in this article uses list prices.
Enterprise+ conflict, RESOLVED. Our #15 (Gate 10 live-verified October 14) recorded Enterprise+ at $45 annual vendor-published. The live page on October 23 shows “Contact sales for pricing” with no $45 figure anywhere — the live page supersedes #15’s $45.
Item-14 anomaly, asserted from the live page. slack.com/pricing is a monthly-only page — there is no annual/monthly toggle — yet the 50%-off-for-3-months promo applies only to monthly billing, bought online within 7 days of team creation; annual plans and Enterprise+ are excluded by the promo’s own T&C. The page publishes no annual Pro or Business+ price at all. If your budget needs annual-billing figures, confirm with the vendor — this article budgets the published monthly list. Verified live at slack.com/pricing, October 23, 2026.
AI is bundled, not an add-on. The live page shows no AI on Free; Basic AI on Pro, Advanced AI on Business+, and Enterprise-grade AI on Enterprise+ — AI is bundled by tier, never a paid add-on. Fair Billing still applies: only members active within 28 days are billed, with prorated credit. Single-channel guests are free (5 per paid member); multi-channel guests are billed as full members. Slack Connect is 1:1 external on Free; paid tiers reach up to 250 external orgs in group Connect channels.
The five alternatives at a glance
| Alternative | Exit reason it serves | Honest entry price (annual, per user/mo) | Headline strength |
|---|---|---|---|
| Microsoft Teams | Ecosystem already paid for | Essentials $4; $0 incremental inside M365 | Chat + meetings inside the Microsoft bill |
| Google Chat | Ecosystem already paid for | Starter $7; $0 incremental inside Workspace | Chat inside the Google bill, Gmail-native |
| Pumble | Cheapest standalone seat / unlimited history | Business $3.99 (recommended; Pro $2.49 lacks guest users) | Unlimited history even at $0 |
| Discord | Community / $0 voice | $0 (Nitro is per-person consumer, not a business plan) | Best voice channels, $0, unlimited history |
| Mattermost | Self-hosted control | $0 licence + hosting (paid tiers = contact sales, no published prices) | Data ownership, self-hosted |
Prices last verified: October 23, 2026 (live vendor pages).
Source legend for every table in this article: “Live vendor page” = the figure as read in the live browser on the vendor’s own pricing page on October 23, 2026. “Third-party: [name]” = a named non-vendor source, hedged. Anything unconfirmed stays “Not published” — never guessed.
1. Microsoft Teams — the Microsoft-365 exit
Judge Teams as “chat you already own,” not as a standalone purchase. If the agency already pays for Microsoft 365, the incremental chat cost is $0 — and that is the entire economic case. If it does not pay for M365, price the bundle honestly: the chat-only entry is Teams Essentials.
Microsoft Teams price ladder (read live on microsoft.com, October 23, 2026)
| Plan | Paid yearly (per user/mo) | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Teams Essentials | $4.00 | Live vendor page |
| Microsoft 365 Business Basic (incl. Teams) | $7.00 | Live vendor page |
| Business Standard with Copilot (incl. Teams) | $23.50 | Live vendor page |
| Teams Enterprise (standalone) | $8.55 | Live vendor page |
Prices last verified: October 23, 2026 (live vendor pages).
Per-table source: read live in the browser on microsoft.com, October 23, 2026. Monthly-billing prices are not shown anywhere on the page. The standalone Business Standard ($14) and Business Premium ($22) cards from earlier crawls are gone — the page now positions Business Standard with Copilot at $23.50.
Three Teams notes that change the bill. First, the July 2026 price move is confirmed live: Business Basic at $7.00 paid yearly (our #15 recorded $6 in October). Second, the add-ons are all per-seat: Teams Premium $10.00/user/mo paid yearly (requires a plan including a Teams Enterprise licence); M365 Copilot Business $18 annual (was $21), eligible M365 subscription required, up to 300 users, promo July 1–December 31, 2026 — an Essentials-only buyer does NOT meet the “eligible M365 subscription” wording, so do not budget Copilot on an Essentials-only bill. Third, Teams Phone IS published on the page: Phone Standard $10.00/user/mo paid yearly (separate Teams licence required); pay-as-you-go calling $13.00; Calling Plan $17.00 (3,000 domestic minutes, US/UK/CA); domestic+international $34.00; Audio Conferencing with dial-out is a no-cost add-on.
Essentials covers meetings up to 30 hours with 300 participants and 10 GB of cloud storage per user. The “already pay for it” test is the verdict: on M365 Business Basic ($7), Teams is already bought — Slack Pro ($8.75) on top of it is a second chat bill for the same headcount. If the agency does NOT pay for M365, buying the whole suite for chat alone is the wrong move — price Essentials $4 instead. Guest access is listed as “included in the version with Teams” for Business Basic and Business Standard with Copilot; the Essentials cell is blank — hedged.
Ceiling: complexity cost. Teams’ chat and search are widely reported as weaker than Slack’s for finding old messages, and the SharePoint/OneDrive sprawl behind teams and channels confuses most users. There is little reason to choose Teams if the agency is not already on Microsoft 365 — say that plainly.
2. Google Chat — the Google-Workspace exit
Same “already own” test as Teams, on the Google side. Chat ships inside every Workspace business plan; the cheapest business route in is Business Starter. Never price the personal free Google account as the business price — a personal account carries no admin, no support, and no compliance story.
Google Workspace price ladder, Chat included (read live on workspace.google.com/pricing, October 23, 2026)
| Plan | Annual commitment (per user/mo) | Flexible monthly (per user/mo) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Business Starter (incl. Chat) | $7 | $8.40 | Live vendor page |
| Business Standard (incl. Chat) | $14 | $16.80 | Live vendor page |
| Business Plus (incl. Chat, Vault) | $22 | $26.40 | Live vendor page |
| Enterprise (incl. Chat) | Contact sales | Contact sales | Live vendor page |
Prices last verified: October 23, 2026 (live vendor pages).
Per-table source: read live in the browser on workspace.google.com/pricing, October 23, 2026. All figures per user/mo in USD; 14-day trial; Business plans cap at 300 users. Gemini in Chat is not supported on the Starter SKU — Standard and up. Vault (retain, archive, search) arrives on Plus ($22). External/guest messaging rules are not stated anywhere on the page — hedged, not asserted.
Three Google Chat notes that change the bill. First, Gemini in Chat is not on Starter: the vendor’s own comparison table shows “Gemini in Chat” as not supported on the Starter SKU and available from Standard up — so AI-assisted chat costs $14/seat, not $7. Second, retention/compliance tiers with Vault: Vault (retain, archive, search) arrives on Business Plus ($22) — an agency that needs Slack-Business+-style compliance exports must price Plus, not Starter. Third, the page carries promo banners (50% off 3 months; 40% off Starter/Standard) — promos, not list; this article budgets list.
Starter carries 30 GB pooled storage per user, Gemini in Gmail, 100-participant video meetings, and the standard Workspace security controls. External/guest messaging rules and per-plan retention caps beyond Vault are not stated on the vendor page — hedged, not asserted.
Ceiling: Chat is the thinnest product in this set — serviceable channels and threads, Gmail/Drive-native, but no Slack-depth workflow builder and an admin story that only gets serious at Plus. Pick it because Workspace is already paid for, not because Chat wins on its own.
3. Pumble — the cheapest-standalone exit
Pumble is the price leader that is actually built for business: unlimited users and unlimited message history even on the Free tier, and the lowest paid seat in the field. Judge it on whether cheap chat holds up at agency headcount — admin, integrations, and client access — not just on the $2.49 headline.
Pumble price ladder (read live on pumble.com/pricing, October 23, 2026)
| Plan | Annual billing (per user/mo) | Monthly billing (per user/mo) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 (unlimited users, unlimited history, unlimited channels, 10 GB/workspace, 1:1 voice & video, up to 3 integrations — Clockify/Plaky excluded) | $0 | Live vendor page |
| Pro | $2.49 | $2.99 | Live vendor page |
| Business | $3.99 | $4.99 | Live vendor page |
| Enterprise | $6.99 | $7.99 | Live vendor page |
Prices last verified: October 23, 2026 (live vendor pages).
Per-table source: read live in the browser on pumble.com/pricing, October 23, 2026. Guest users arrive on Business ($3.99) — the vendor FAQ confirms multi-channel guests are billed as full members. The opt-in AI assistant’s price is not stated on the page — “Not published.”
Three Pumble notes that change the bill. First, the $2.49 teaser is not the agency price: per pumble.com, guest users — the client-communication test — arrive on Business ($3.99), which also adds user groups, role-based access, meeting recording, and unlimited integrations. The live page confirms Business — this article recommends Business and prices it. Second, storage steps with the tier: 10 GB per workspace on Free, then 10/20/100 GB per user on Pro/Business/Enterprise. Third, the CAKE.com Productivity Suite bundles Pumble + Plaky (task management) + Clockify (time tracking) at $12.99/seat/mo annual or $15.99 monthly — combined value $27.97, a 53% saving. The opt-in AI assistant’s price is not stated on the page — “Not published.”
Ceiling: ecosystem depth. Pumble has no 2,600-app directory, SSO waits for Enterprise ($6.99), and data retention controls are an Enterprise feature. It is a chat tool, not a platform — which is exactly the right shape for a 10-person agency and the wrong shape for a compliance-led 100-person one.
4. Discord — the community exit, with a ceiling
Discord is $0 with unlimited message history and the best voice channels in this set — and it is not a business tool. Its paid tiers are per-person consumer upgrades, not per-seat business plans: never present Nitro as “Discord’s paid plan” for a team.
Discord plan structure (read live on discord.com/nitro, October 23, 2026)
| Tier | Price | What it is | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 (unlimited history, voice channels, video, screen sharing, ~10 MB file uploads) | The whole product, per person | Live vendor page |
| Nitro Basic | Not published on the vendor page — the FAQ defers to in-app (User Settings > Nitro); cost varies by country (third-party reports cite $2.99/mo, $29.99/yr — hedged) | Consumer perks: 50 MB uploads, custom emoji/stickers anywhere, super reactions, video backgrounds | Live vendor page (plan structure); third-party (price) |
| Nitro | Not published on the vendor page — same FAQ deferral (third-party reports cite $9.99/mo, $99.99/yr — hedged) | Consumer perks: 1 GB uploads, HD streaming, 2 Server Boosts + 30% off extras, 4,000-char messages, 200-server cap | Live vendor page (plan structure); third-party (price) |
Prices last verified: October 23, 2026 (live vendor pages).
Per-table source: read live in the browser on discord.com/nitro, October 23, 2026. The plan structure (consumer perks, Server Boosts) is page-observed; the dollar figures are NOT verifiable on the page — the FAQ says cost varies by country and points to in-app pricing. Nothing on the page as read promises an SLA, business support, SSO, compliance exports, or a data-processing agreement — that absence is the ceiling.
The vendor page describes a consumer subscription: “enhance your Discord experience” — per account, bought in User Settings, cancellable per device. Server Boosts (2 included with Nitro) unlock perks for a community server, not admin controls for a company. Moderation tooling is community-oriented (roles, permissions, bots), not IT-admin oriented.
The honest agency use: internal creative teams and communities that already live on Discord, at $0, with unlimited history. The dishonest one: putting client work on a platform whose business tier does not exist. Client-grade external communication — the agency test this article runs — is not something Discord sells.
Ceiling, stated plainly: no SLA, no business support, no admin/compliance story, no per-seat billing, no client data controls. A Nitro subscription buys one person bigger uploads and HD streaming — it does not buy the agency anything.
5. Mattermost — the self-hosted exit
Mattermost’s free entry is a limited-use edition of Enterprise Advanced for technical evaluation — the vendor page does not name a “Team Edition.” The honest price is the total cost of running it: hosting + updates + maintenance + whoever owns it. Self-hosted is not free — it is unbilled.
Mattermost price position (no published prices — read live October 23, 2026)
| Plan | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Free entry (self-hosted) | Limited-use edition of Enterprise Advanced for technical evaluation — $0 licence + hosting + your ops time | Live vendor page |
| Professional | Contact sales — no published price (third-party reports cite $10/user/mo, hedged) | Live vendor page; third-party |
| Enterprise | Get pricing — contact Mattermost sales for current packaging | Live vendor page |
| Enterprise Advanced | Request quote — contact Mattermost sales for current packaging | Live vendor page |
Prices last verified: October 23, 2026 (live vendor pages).
Per-table source: read live in the browser on the vendor pricing page, October 23, 2026. Paid tiers are per-seat prepaid annual licences. The $10/user/mo Professional figure is NOT on the page — it is third-party-reported (G2, TrustRadius), hedged, and NOT asserted here. Boards (Kanban) are Enterprise and Enterprise Advanced only, not Professional; guest accounts are included in all three paid tiers; Playbooks are not listed on the page.
The self-hosted math, from third-party hosting examples: a VPS in the 4 GB class (the 10–30 seat band) runs roughly $15–30/mo; the 8 GB class (30–80 seats) roughly $26–53/mo. So a 10-person agency’s chat infrastructure is on the order of $180–360/yr in hosting — plus the unpriced line item: someone’s hours for updates, backups, and uptime. For the contact-sales tiers, contact Mattermost sales for current packaging instead of relying on any package detail printed here.
No pricing-inversion callout (item 14). The third-party reports put Professional at $10/user/mo — more per seat than Slack Pro’s $8.75, before hosting — but the vendor page publishes no Professional price, so the inversion cannot be asserted. If Mattermost quotes you a per-seat figure, work the bill against Slack Pro’s $8.75 before buying.
Ceiling: you are the ops team. Updates, backups, uptime, and security patches are your job — the licence is $0, the operations are not. Agencies without someone who will own the server should not self-host chat.
Worked bills: 10-person and 50-person agencies (annual billing)
Recommended tiers, list prices, every seat occupied. The per-occupied-seat figure is the bill divided by headcount — all bills below assume full occupancy; only Slack publishes an occupied-seat rule (Fair Billing credits seats inactive 28+ days). (Worked-bill format follows our Monday real-cost teardown.)
| Annual bill (recommended tier) | 10 seats/mo | 10 seats/yr | Per occupied seat | 50 seats/mo | 50 seats/yr | Per occupied seat | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Slack Pro $8.75 | $87.50 | $1,050 | $8.75 | $437.50 | $5,250 | $8.75 | Live vendor page |
| Slack Business+ $18 | $180 | $2,160 | $18.00 | $900 | $10,800 | $18.00 | Live vendor page |
| Teams Essentials $4 | $40 | $480 | $4.00 | $200 | $2,400 | $4.00 | Live vendor page |
| M365 Basic $7 — already-pay route: $0 incremental | $70 ($0 if already paying) | $840 ($0) | $7.00 ($0) | $350 ($0) | $4,200 ($0) | $7.00 ($0) | Live vendor page |
| Workspace Starter $7 — already-pay route: $0 incremental | $70 ($0 if already paying) | $840 ($0) | $7.00 ($0) | $350 ($0) | $4,200 ($0) | $7.00 ($0) | Live vendor page |
| Pumble Pro $2.49 (shown to show the trap — no guest users) | $24.90 | $298.80 | $2.49 | $124.50 | $1,494 | $2.49 | Live vendor page |
| Pumble Business $3.99 (recommended) | $39.90 | $478.80 | $3.99 | $199.50 | $2,394 | $3.99 | Live vendor page |
| Discord $0 (Nitro excluded — per-person consumer, not a business plan) | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | Live vendor page |
| Mattermost: $0 licence + flat hosting (paid tiers = contact sales, no published prices) | $15–30 | $180–360 | $1.50–3.00 | $15–30 | $180–360 | $0.30–0.60 | Live vendor page (tiers); third-party (hosting) |
Prices last verified: October 23, 2026 (live vendor pages).
Per-table source: arithmetic recomputed from the live ladder figures above; the flat hosting band is third-party host examples (promo pricing included in the range). Year-one Slack Pro at 50 seats with the 50%-off-3-months promo = 3 × $218.75 + 9 × $437.50 = $4,593.75 — promo, not list; every bill here uses list.
The sharpest read: a 50-person agency on Slack Pro pays $5,250/yr list; the same headcount on Pumble Business pays $2,394/yr — a $2,856/yr gap for unlimited-history chat with guest users (50 × $8.75 × 12 = $5,250; $5,250 − $2,394 = $2,856). On Pumble Free the gap is the whole $5,250. And the “already pay for it” rows are the real story for bundled shops: if M365 or Workspace is already on the invoice, the chat bill is $0 incremental — do not buy a second chat product for the same headcount.
True-cost table: headline price is the floor (item 19 billing-basis split)
Per-seat add-ons multiply with headcount; flat add-ons do not. The split is shown, not smoothed over.
| Tool | Headline plan | Add-on | Billing basis | 10-seat true cost/mo | 50-seat true cost/mo | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Slack Pro | $8.75/seat (monthly billing — the only billing published) | AI bundled by tier (none on Free; no paid add-on); Frontline teams add-on = Not published | Per-seat | $87.50 | $437.50 | Live vendor page |
| Teams Essentials | $4/seat (paid yearly) | Teams Premium $10 (paid yearly; requires a plan including a Teams Enterprise licence); Copilot Business $18 (annual; eligible M365 subscription required — Essentials-only buyers do NOT meet the wording); Teams Phone Standard $10 (paid yearly; separate Teams licence required); Audio Conferencing with dial-out = no-cost add-on | Per-seat | $40 (+$100 with Premium; +$180 with Copilot if eligible; +$100 with Phone Standard) | $200 (+$500; +$900; +$500) | Live vendor page |
| Google Chat via Starter | $7/seat annual-commit ($8.40 flexible monthly) | Gemini in Chat needs Standard $14 (tier upgrade); Vault needs Plus $22 (tier upgrade) | Per-seat | $70 ($140 on Standard; $220 on Plus) | $350 ($700; $1,100) | Live vendor page |
| Pumble Business | $3.99/seat | CAKE.com bundle (Pumble+Plaky+Clockify) $12.99/seat annual or $15.99 monthly (combined value $27.97, save 53%); AI assistant = Not published | Per-seat | $39.90 ($129.90 with bundle) | $199.50 ($649.50) | Live vendor page |
| Discord | $0 | Nitro — price not published on the vendor page (FAQ defers to in-app; varies by country); per-person consumer upgrade, never added to a team bill | N/A (consumer) | $0 | $0 | Live vendor page |
| Mattermost self-hosted | $0 licence (limited-use Enterprise Advanced edition) | Hosting $15–30/mo (flat — same at both sizes); maintenance time = Not published (unpriced); paid tiers = contact sales, no published prices | Flat | $15–30 + time | $15–30 + time | Live vendor page; third-party (hosting) |
Prices last verified: October 23, 2026 (live vendor pages).
Per-table source: every figure read live in the browser on the vendor pricing pages, October 23, 2026. Unpriced add-ons are “Not published,” never estimated, never blended into a per-seat average. Misclassifying a flat add-on as per-seat (or vice versa) is a gate FAIL at Gate 10.
Read the Teams row carefully: a 50-person agency that adds Teams Premium pays $500/mo in per-seat add-ons on top of a $200/mo plan — the add-on is 2.5× the plan ($10 vs the $4 Essentials plan, and the Premium T&C require a plan including a Teams Enterprise licence). And Copilot Business at $18 annual (was $21) is only budgetable on an eligible Microsoft 365 subscription — an Essentials-only buyer does not meet the eligibility wording.
Per-plan limit matrix: the limits that decide upgrades
| Limit | Slack | Teams | Google Chat | Pumble | Discord | Mattermost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Message history | Free: 90 days visible (upgrade restores 12 months; deleted after 1 year). Paid: unlimited | Unlimited chat history reported (incl. Free) — third-party | Retention by tier; Vault on Plus ($22) | Unlimited, all plans | Unlimited | Unlimited (your storage) |
| Integrations / apps | Free: 10 apps (2,600+ directory). Paid: unlimited | 700+ reported — third-party | Via Workspace apps | Free: 3 (Clockify/Plaky excluded). Pro: 10. Business+: unlimited | Bots; no business app directory | 700+ reported — third-party |
| Storage | Not published as vendor-verified (#15) | Free: 5 GB; Essentials: 10 GB/user — third-party | Starter: 30 GB pooled/user | 10 GB/workspace Free; 10/20/100 GB per seat paid | ~10 MB free file uploads (vendor docs FAQ) | Your disk |
| Guest / external access | Single-channel guests free (5/paid member); multi-channel = full seat; Connect 1:1 external Free, group external up to 250 orgs paid | Guest access “included in the version with Teams” for Business Basic and Business Standard with Copilot; Essentials cell blank — hedged | Not stated on the page — hedged | Guest users from Business ($3.99); multi-channel guests = full members | Invite-based servers; no guest billing concept | Guest accounts included in all three paid tiers (live vendor page) |
| SSO / admin | OAuth-Google Free; SAML SSO Business+; Multi-SAML Enterprise+ | Entra ID story — tier not confirmed on page as read | Admin via Workspace; Vault Plus | SSO on Enterprise ($6.99) | No business admin story | SSO incl. self-hosted — third-party |
| Meetings / huddles | 1:1 huddles Free; group paid | Free: 60-min/100-part; Essentials: 30h/300-part | Via Meet: 100-part Starter | 1:1 Free; group meetings paid | Voice channels free — best in set | Via plugin (e.g. Jitsi) — third-party |
| Boards / playbooks | Not a native feature | Via Planner (separate M365 app) | Not a native feature | Not a native feature | Not a native feature | Boards (Kanban): Enterprise and Enterprise Advanced ONLY — not Professional; Playbooks: not listed on the vendor page |
Prices last verified: October 23, 2026 (live vendor pages).
Per-table source: limits read live on the vendor pages October 23, 2026 or from the same sources as the pricing tables; anything not on a vendor page as read is third-party or hedged — never guessed. The history row is the article’s sharpest table: Slack Free’s 90-day cap against Pumble/Discord/Mattermost unlimited and Teams/Chat retention-by-plan.
Decision framework: the pick follows the reason
Per exit reason — one pick, one runner-up:
- Per-seat cost at headcount → Pumble Business ($3.99/seat). Unlimited history, guest users for client access, $2,394/yr at 50 seats against Slack Pro’s $5,250. Runner-up: Teams Essentials ($4) if the agency also needs real meetings.
- Ecosystem already paid for → Teams (Microsoft-365 shops) / Google Chat (Workspace shops). $0 incremental on the M365 Business Basic ($7) or Workspace Starter ($7) bill the agency already pays. Runner-up: if neither bundle is paid, do not buy a suite for chat alone — price Teams Essentials ($4) or Pumble instead.
- Cheapest standalone seat / unlimited history → Pumble Free ($0). Unlimited users and unlimited history, forever, per pumble.com. Runner-up: Discord Free ($0, unlimited history, best voice) — internal/creative teams only, never client work.
- Self-hosted control → Mattermost free entry (limited-use Enterprise Advanced edition, self-hosted). $0 licence + $15–30/mo hosting + your ops time. Runner-up: Rocket.Chat self-hosted (mentioned only — no section here).
Per buyer segment:
- Freelancers & boutiques (1–5): Pumble Free at $0; step to Business ($3.99 × 5 = $19.95/mo) when client guests enter.
- Growing full-service (6–25): Teams at $0 incremental inside M365, or Pumble Business at $3.99 for standalone buyers; Workspace shops take Google Chat at $0 incremental.
- Large & multi-brand (25+): Teams on the Microsoft 365 Business Standard with Copilot track ($23.50) for Microsoft-led orgs; Mattermost Enterprise (get pricing) or Enterprise Advanced (request quote) for data-ownership requirements.
Also in the field, not covered in depth: Chanty — a chat tool with a task board attached, aimed at very small teams; outside this article’s agency scope, no section here. WhatsApp is deliberately excluded: personal messaging with no channels, no admin controls, and no compliance story — it is not team chat. Twist is the async-first tool some teams ask about; async-by-design is not an agency need, so it gets this line and no more.
Switching guide: leaving Slack without losing the archive
What you gain: the per-seat math above (up to $5,250/yr at 50 seats on Pumble Free); history permanence on every alternative in this set; and — for bundled shops — one fewer invoice, since Teams/Google Chat are already paid for.
What you lose: Slack Connect cross-org channels (rebuild per tool — none of these five replicates Connect one-to-one); the 2,600-app directory depth (Pumble’s caps and Teams’ 700+ are real steps down); Workflow Builder automations (Slack’s export mechanics for workflows are not stated on the pricing page — verify in Slack’s export docs during the trial, and assume rebuild-by-hand); and Slack’s Fair Billing (only Slack credits inactive seats here).
The steps:
- Audit: list every Slack channel, integration, workflow, guest, and Connect channel — and flag which ones only exist on paid tiers, because those are the ones that must re-price on the new tool’s equivalent tier.
- Export: pull message history and files out of Slack BEFORE cutover. On Free, older messages are hidden after 90 days and deleted after a year — start the export while the workspace still has its history.
- Trial segment: run one live client project on the new tool for two weeks — not a demo workspace, a real project with a real client in the guest/external seat.
- Rebuild money automations first: client onboarding pings, notification zaps, status updates — before nice-to-have views. Count one week of message volume against the new tool’s history and storage caps.
- Parallel warm-up: run Slack and the new tool side by side for one billing cycle on the trial project.
- Cutover: move the remaining channels, re-point integrations, re-test every automation, then cancel Slack.
No migration timeline is stated here: it depends on how many channels, integrations, and automations the agency built, and any source quoting one is guessing.
We have no affiliate relationship with Slack, Microsoft, Google, Pumble, Discord, or Mattermost — every CTA on this page is a plain vendor link.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Slack alternative is cheapest for a 10-person agency?
Pumble Free: $0 with unlimited users and unlimited history. On a paid tier, Pumble Business is $39.90/mo ($478.80/yr) for 10 seats with guest users; Teams Essentials is $40/mo; Slack Pro itself is $87.50/mo ($1,050/yr). Prices last verified: October 23, 2026 (live vendor pages).
Is Pumble really free forever? What are the limits?
Per pumble.com, the Free tier carries unlimited users, unlimited message history, and unlimited channels, with 10 GB of storage per workspace, 1:1 voice and video, and up to 3 integrations (Clockify/Plaky excluded). Group meetings, screen sharing, 10 GB per user, and guest users sit on paid tiers from $2.49/seat/mo (Business at $3.99 adds guest users). Prices last verified: October 23, 2026 (live vendor pages).
Can I use Discord for my agency’s client communication?
Not as a business tool. Discord is $0 with unlimited history and the best voice channels here, but its paid tiers are per-person consumer upgrades (Nitro — price not published on the vendor page) — there is no per-seat business plan, no SLA, no business support, and no admin/compliance story on the vendor page as read. Fine for an internal creative team; not for client work.
How do I keep my chat history when leaving Slack?
Export before cutover. Slack Free shows only the last 90 days; upgrading restores the previous 12 months, and the vendor’s comparison table states Free data is deleted after one year. Audit every channel, integration, workflow, guest, and Connect channel; export history and files while the workspace still holds them; then trial, rebuild automations by hand, parallel-run one billing cycle, and cut over.
Do clients need paid seats on these Slack alternatives?
It depends on the tool. Slack gives 5 free single-channel guests per paid member but bills multi-channel guests as full seats. Pumble adds guest users on Business ($3.99). Teams lists guest access as “included in the version with Teams” for Business Basic and Business Standard with Copilot (Essentials cell blank — hedged); Google Chat’s external/guest rules are not stated on the vendor page — check during the trial. Discord has no guest billing concept (invite-based servers); Mattermost guest accounts are included in all three paid tiers per the vendor page.
What does self-hosting Mattermost actually cost?
The licence is $0; the total is not. Third-party hosting examples put a 10–30 seat VPS at roughly $15–30/mo ($180–360/yr) and a 30–80 seat box at roughly $26–53/mo — plus someone’s hours for updates, backups, and uptime, which is the real line item and is unpriced. Mattermost publishes no Professional-tier price (third-party reports cite $10/user/mo — hedged, not asserted); the free entry is a limited-use edition of Enterprise Advanced for technical evaluation. Prices last verified: October 23, 2026 (live vendor pages).
We may earn a commission if you buy through our links — it doesn’t change our verdicts.

Dr. Abdullah
Dr. Abdullah is the founder of Agency Tested, a research publication that scores B2B SaaS tools for marketing agencies. Every product is assessed against vendor documentation, live pricing pages, and verified user reports — never faked hands-on tests. Every score on this site carries his name and his rulebook.